Romantic Angst – how much is too much?

A handsome alien man and a human woman looking angry at each other. They have their backs to each other, glaring.

Romantic angst, simply put, is the emotional conflict and inner or outer turmoil that afflicts a relationship. How this takes shape in fiction can vary wildly, but there is always a struggle to deal with and, hopefully, overcome.

This deep emotional chaos can either move a plot to profound highs or sink it into a cesspit of frustrating near misses. It’s a necessary evil, and not a bad one when handled skillfully.

A while back I started reading my way through a very well-known sci-fi fantasy romance series. I won’t name names because that’s not cool, but I was surprised by how popular this series is because it quickly became annoying as hell.

Many of the characters are quite likeable, and that’s really what saves it. An adorable main character can cover many an overused trope or gaping plot hole. To a point, at least.

Ways that angst gets overplayed

There are many good uses for romantic tension, misunderstandings and plain old stubbornness. These are time-tested elements that can work quite well but, speaking as a reader, they get frustrating if not wielded properly. Here are some examples.

Stuck on repeat

In this particular series, I noticed a pattern beginning to form as the author got deeper into the series. There is usually one major obstacle between the love interests and it never, ever, wants to go away. Until it’s suddenly sorted out in an instant like the snapping of fingers and everyone’s happy.

So, how many times do you need to have the same fight? How many times does the heroine need to mull over the exact same fear or assumption? In the case of the last book I read, it went on for over a hundred pages. Not the whole book, just that particular dither. That’s a lot. And it felt like every bit of a lot because that was the only element propelling the story at that point.

No new ground was covered, or if it was, it made no difference once someone said something to the heroine that annoyed her again. Despite the alien heartthrob revealing his painful past, along with his washboard abs (I’m not complaining about that), the inevitably abducted human lass feels a couple of moments of sympathy and then plows onward with her stubborn and unrealistic schemes. Over and over again.

At that point I began skimming.

The problem was too easily solved

Well, I mean it should have been. Seriously, if a five-minute conversation would have been enough to settle the whole damn issue, it’s hard to justify spending a dozen chapters on it.

All the MMC had to do was verbalize a fraction of his thoughts about this cranky woman. That would’ve sorted it all out and they’d have been mating like space bunnies much sooner.

I’m not saying the author needed to dream up a hugely convoluted problem for them to face. Frankly, when the cover features multi-hued man-teats, you know not to expect a deep dive into anyone’s higher consciousness. All I’m saying is that you need to justify the page count. They do need to have some decent reason to be mad at each other for that long.

A couple looking at each other from a distance.

Being mean isn’t a satisfying reason

The heroine gets miffed, again about the same stuff, and says something horribly cutting. Space-cutie is hurt and she feels badly about it. But she doesn’t apologize because… she feels she wasn’t wrong. Why does she feel guilty if she didn’t do anything wrong?

Angst.

Why apologise for a hastily spoken comment when you can let it simmer and keep the easily solved problem alive? At this point I skimmed some more and giggled at the thought of colorful man-teats.

Easy, angst-filled solutions

What would have made this couple’s single problem pull its weight more gracefully?

Subplots

Subplots are smaller, often closely related, side stories that weave through the book. They add depth, insight and enjoyment by expanding on the story and perhaps revealing more about side characters. They’re a very good and necessary thing, unless you’re writing a novella or short story. But that’s another discussion.

Now, this book I just read did incorporate a subplot. But it wasn’t until well into the second half of the book. That is way too late, in my opinion, because a bored or frustrated reader might well give up long before that point if the story’s been going around in a tight little circle. I persisted, but I skipped over a lot.

If glimpses of the new and ominous problem had been given earlier, it would have put a little meat on the bones. Given us a breather between the domestic dramas and kept things interesting. Instead, we were left with the same stupidly unnecessary argument on repeat and then a huge curveball thrown in out of nowhere.

A shorter book

This book was about 260-ish pages, not huge but not short either. Yet, every time the couple lapsed into the same pattern of behavior, I checked the page number and sighed when I realized I wasn’t even halfway through. Quite a bit could have been trimmed without really losing anything.

Now, as a writer, I do sympathise. When you create a story, it’s easy to view every scene as precious and important to the reading experience. Sometimes that simply isn’t the case, but it’s hard for the author to see that. That’s where good editors and plucky beta readers can help.

A stack of romance novels wrapped in chains and a padlock.
Not every word is sacred.

I read another reader’s review and in it she complained that nothing happened in the book. While it sounds exaggerated, she had a point. There wasn’t enough happening to require that much page time, and what little was happening quickly became irritating.

Approaching the situation as a reader, I’d say that this author’s bacon is saved because she does a good job of writing loveable, cinnamon roll alien hunks. In the genre she writes, that is genuinely a skill to be pleased about, so I say a quite sincere good for her. But, to be honest, I abandoned the series and I have no interest in going back to it.

I take it as a cautionary example of how mishandled angst can sink a book. Or an entire series in this case. Problems faced and conquered make a romance compelling, but the problems need to justify the reactions. That will make the final triumph all the sweeter.